Order Food

We are now taking custom cake orders (for pick up at store location). Cake options and pricing below.

To order, please contact us at info@bananaramabakery.com To expedite the ordering process, please copy and paste the order form text into your message (until we set up a more direct ordering system). Pickup address is 15-2929 Pahoa Village Road, Pahoa. Upon ordering, a link will be sent for payment. Your cake is not ordered until payment is received. You must arrange pick up on the day you specify.

Please place your order 1 week or more before the day you’ll pick it up.

Bananarama Bakery Cake Order Form

Your name: 

email address: 

Contact phone:                      Text ok?

Date to pick up: 

Cake diameter (inches): 6, 9, 12, 14

Number of layers: 2, 3, 4 

Cake flavor:

Frosting Flavor: 

Decoration colors (one frosting color included): 


Bananarama Bakery Cake Flavor and Price List

Cake SizeServesLevel 1Level 2Gluten free
6” 2 layer2-4$35$41Add $4
6” 3 layer3-6$40$46Add $4
9” 2 layer6-12$50$56Add $5
9” 3 layer12-16$65$71Add $6
12” 2 layer16-30$100$112Add $10
12” 3 layer30-50$150$162Add $14

We also now sell Cookie Cakes, which are a large cookies with your choice of frosting. Available in Chocolate Chip, with Paniolo, Lemon Poppyseed, Oatmeal, and Snickerdoodle coming soon!

Cookie Cake12”14”16”
Any kind-regular$40$50$62
Gluten Free$45$57$70
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

Cupcakes: 1 dozen minimum. Sold by the dozen. $3-$3.75 each depending on flavor, filling, decoration. Most cake flavors available as cupcakes. GF- add $3 per dozen. 

Sugar free-(using Erythritol)— message for quote

Tiered cakes and larger cakes— message for a quote

Level 1 Flavors

Almond/ Lemon Cream– almond cake with lemon cream frosting

Lemon Almond Cake

Banana Caramel-banana cake with caramel frosting. One of our 3 signature cakes!

Banana Caramel Cake

Banana Chocolate Chip-banana cake with chocolate chips and chocolate frosting

Banana Chocolate and Pandan Cakes

Chocolate-chocolate cake with chocolate frosting (or any other frosting)

Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Orange-orange cake, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Orange Cake

Chocolate Peanut Butter – chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake

Coconut-coconut cake with coconut frosting, covered in coconut

Coconut Cake

Coconut Lilikoi-coconut cake, lilikoi frosting. One of our 3 signature cakes! 

Ube Coconut, Coconut Lilikoi, & Pandan Cakes

Kona Mocha Fudge– chocolate cake, mocha frosting. One of our 3 signature cakes!

Kona Mocha Fudge Cake

Lemon-lemon cake with vanilla frosting

Lemon Ginger-lemon ginger cake with candied ginger bits and lemon or vanilla frosting

Lemon Poppyseed-lemon poppyseed cake with vanilla frosting

Lemon Poppyseed Cake

Pandan– green pandan cake, coconut blossom frosting

Pandan Cake with Coconut Sugar Frosting

Piña Colada-pineapple rum cake, coconut frosting

Red Velvet– red velvet cake with tangy vanilla frosting

Tropical Dream-pineapple brown sugar cake, lilikoi frosting

Tropical Dream Cake

Yellow cake with any frosting

Level 2 Flavors

Banana Cream Pie-banana cake, banana cream filling, vanilla frosting, graham cracker crumble

Banana Cream Pie Cake

Carrot Cake-carrot cake with pineapple and coconut and tangy vanilla frosting

Carrot Cake

Chocolate Lilikoi -chocolate cake, lilikoi curd filling, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Lilikoi Cake

Chocolate Raspberry-chocolate cake, raspberry frosting

Chocolate Raspberry Cake

German Chocolate– chocolate cake, toasted coconut and pecan filling, chocolate frosting

German Chocolate Cake

Lemon Blueberry-lemon blueberry cake, blueberry filling, vanilla frosting

Mango Lime-mango lime cake with chunks of mango in it with mango frosting

Orange Cranberry– orange cranberry cake with orange frosting

Cranberry Orange Cake

Samoa Cake-(like the Girl Scout cookie) chocolate cake, caramel frosting, covered in toasted coconut, caramel and chocolate drizzle

Samoa Cake

Strawberry Shortcake-yellow cake, strawberry filling, vanilla frosting

Strawberry Shortcake

Triple Chocolate– chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, and chocolate ganache

Volcano Cake-chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, lilikoi lava glaze (has a bit of heat from chipotle in the glaze)

Tres leches cake-a single layer sheet cake soaked with sweetened condensed soy milk, coconut cream and whipped coconut topping -9×13 size serves up to 24 -$55; 13×18 size serves up to 48- $110